AlamyLaunched in 1946, Frank Capra’s It is a Great Life was derided as an “over-sentimental” Christmas yarn. In Historical past appears to be like at how its profound exploration of psychological well being, societal expectations and the therapeutic energy of neighborhood resonates at this time.
Within the eight many years since its launch, It is a Great Life has grow to be a sacrosanct a part of the vacation interval. James Stewart stars as George Bailey, a financial savings and loans supervisor who contemplates taking his personal life till an angel exhibits him a imaginative and prescient of how a lot worse off his city and his family members could be if he had by no means been born. Because of a clerical oversight, the movie’s copyright expired in 1974, and the following tv broadcasts cemented its repute as a Christmas classic. And but, even in 1974, its director Frank Capra was nonetheless having to defend it from the cost of being “over-sentimental”.
“I feel it was in all probability the strongest image I’ve made,” Capra informed a BBC reporter in an episode of Movie Additional. “I feel it is my favorite movie as a result of it epitomises every thing I attempted to say in all the opposite movies in a single bundle.”
On its launch in 1946, Bosley Crowther of The New York Instances critiqued It is a Great Life for its tone, noting that “the weak point of this image is the sentimentality of it”. Capra’s earlier film-making was equally related to sentimental, idealised variations of US life. Works resembling Mr Deeds Goes to City and Mr Smith Goes to Washington have been labelled “Capra-corn” due to their candy, unassuming nature. Nonetheless, whereas It is a Great Life concludes with pure-hearted George profitable out over the greed-ridden Mr Potter (Lionel Barrymore), the movie exposes the grim, unstated struggles of the bizarre man. In an period of masculine stoicism, when psychological well being went largely undiscussed, Stewart’s portrayal of George’s desperation addressed points of tension, melancholy and the sense of private failure.
The common everyman he performed was additionally a departure from his earlier heroic roles, marking the transformation of his persona each on and off display screen. In 1973, he would describe his on-screen persona on Michael Parkinson’s chat present. “I am the plodder. I am the inarticulate man that tries. I am a reasonably good instance of true human frailty. I do not actually have all of the solutions. I’ve only a few of the solutions, however for some purpose, in some way, I make it. I get via.”
George’s particular private struggles might not have been shared by Stewart, however as a veteran not lengthy again from World Struggle Two, the actor had his personal psychological well being points. “It is the primary image I did after I bought out of the service,” Stewart informed BBC audiences in 1972. It could be nearly 4 many years earlier than post-traumatic stress dysfunction (PTSD) could be added to the Diagnostic and Statistical Handbook of psychological issues (DSM). Veterans have been typically identified with “shell shock” or “fight fatigue” and confronted many difficulties whereas reintegrating again into civilian life.
‘I broke down sobbing’
In an period of stiff higher lips, Stewart’s efficiency was weak, emotionally trustworthy, and typically devastating. Close to the start of the movie, George prays for assist whereas ingesting in a bar within the fictional city of Bedford Falls, New York – and he begins to weep. He considers himself a failure. After a lifetime of placing his private desires apart, and making sacrifice after sacrifice, he has misplaced all sense of self-worth.
George’s tears on this scene have been Stewart’s personal, real and unplanned. He would later clarify in a 1987 retrospective for Guideposts, “As I stated these phrases, I felt the loneliness, the hopelessness of people that had nowhere to show, and my eyes crammed with tears. I broke down sobbing.” Stewart’s genuine feelings transcend the stigmas of his day. George’s lack of ability to hunt assist and his overwhelming sense of failure spoke of an period during which emotional issues have been seen as shameful or insignificant. However what was as soon as written off as sentimentality finds new and higher appreciation amid at this time’s conversations surrounding psychological well being.
Mary Hatch Bailey (Donna Reed), George’s childhood sweetheart and devoted spouse, additionally displays the function anticipated of her on the time, in that she largely acts in keeping with conventional views of womanhood. Like George, she is a selfless character, making most of the identical sacrifices as her husband and serving to him nonetheless she will be able to. However whereas we observe George’s life, setbacks and interior turmoil, Mary’s go unexplored. Not like the distinguished ladies in earlier Capra movies who assert their independence, Mary is a drive of quiet, unwavering help. She performs an important function in George’s salvation, however her efforts go unsung. The movie’s angle in direction of ladies can be seen in Mary’s destiny within the alternate actuality the place George was by no means born. Within the nightmarish Pottersville, the place dying, greed, and abuse have befallen George’s closest mates, Mary’s supposedly horrible life is just that of an single, bespectacled librarian.
The opposite most distinguished ladies within the movie, George’s mom and his childhood pal, adhere to those identical societal expectations. Irene Bailey (Beulah Bondi) is a steadfast mom with little screentime, whereas the flirtatious vixen Violet Bick (Gloria Grahame) acts as a foil to the accountable, honourable Mary. After George’s outburst to his frightened household, it’s Mary who encourages their children to hope for him. On this means, she has a direct hand within the divine intervention he experiences within the type of Clarence Odbody, the wingless angel.
However Mary is not alone. Clarence is distributed to George due to the prayers of all of the individuals he touched throughout his life in Bedford Falls. On this means, Clarence is a manifestation of the help and kindness George has given to the city. His salvation finally comes within the last scene, when his household and mates arrive to alleviate his monetary burdens. On this climactic second, his troubles are mitigated by the very neighborhood he has helped to construct. This cathartic act illustrates the profound therapeutic energy of neighborhood and a way of belonging.
It is a Great Life explored the toll of sacrifice, the ripples of kindness, and the salvation provided by human connection at a time when movies tended to prioritise optimism over psychological complexity. George’s doubts about his personal self-worth, given authenticity by Stewart’s portrayal, resonate in at this time’s world with its ongoing challenges associated to psychological well being, financial hardship and societal pressures. It’s in seeing his life via a distinct lens, sharing his burdens and accepting assist from his neighborhood that George accepts the reality. He isn’t alone, his life has not been futile and he’s not nugatory. As his brother Harry says in a toast on the finish of the movie, George Bailey is “the richest man on the town”.
For extra tales and never-before-published radio scripts to your inbox, signal as much as the In History newsletter, whereas The Essential List delivers a handpicked collection of options and insights twice every week.
